The Sigma 17-40mm F1.8 DC Art Lens Review
Can the Sigma 17-40mm f/1.8 Replace a Full Prime Kit for Night Street Photography?
This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.
When Sigma announced the new 17-40mm f/1.8 for Fuji X-Mount, one question immediately came to mind: could this lens replace my entire kit of fast prime lenses for night shooting? After spending a couple of weeks testing it out in New York City, I wanted to share my impressions.
Why Fast Primes Have Been My Go-To
Lately, I’ve been obsessed with shooting street photography at night in New York. Since I shoot handheld without a tripod, fast lenses are a must. That’s led me to build out a small prime collection: the 23mm f/1.4, 35mm f/1.4, and 56mm f/1.2.
I love these lenses, but using a kit of primes has one big drawback: analysis paralysis. I constantly debate which lens to bring. I’ll mount the 56mm and wish I had the 23, or take the 23 and wish I had the 35. That leads to swapping lenses mid-scene, and sometimes missing the shot entirely.
Why the Sigma 17-40mm Caught My Eye
So when Sigma announced the 17-40mm f/1.8, I was intrigued. Not because the focal length range itself is unique, but because of the constant f/1.8 aperture. That’s essentially unheard of in a zoom. Most zooms are f/2.8 or slower, which just isn’t fast enough for handheld night shooting in my opinion.
This lens sounded like the perfect solution to my problem: the flexibility of a zoom combined with the speed of primes.
Sigma was kind enough to send me a copy to try out (not sponsored, and all opinions here are my own), and after a few weeks of use, here are my thoughts.
Build & Design
Sigma 17-40 f1.8 ART in NYC for street photography at night
Here are some quick specs:
Focal range: 17mm–40mm (about 25–60mm full-frame equivalent)
Constant f/1.8 aperture
Internal zoom (doesn’t extend when zooming)
Aperture ring for tactile control
The size of the front element of the Sigma 17-40 f1.8 ART for Fujifilm
First impressions: yes, it’s a little big, but not nearly as large as I expected. It’s slightly longer than the Fuji 16-55mm f/2.8, but noticeably thinner. The size makes sense—fast glass needs a larger front element.
The build quality is solid, even though it’s mostly plastic. It doesn’t feel cheap, and the weight, while heavier than most of my primes, is still lighter than carrying multiple primes at once.
Internal zooming on the Sigma 17-40 f1.8 ART
I especially like the internal zoom for durability and dust resistance, and the aperture ring feels right at home on Fuji bodies. For me, physical controls keep me more present while shooting, which is part of why I love Fujifilm cameras.
Field Use: Real-World Experience
Over the past few weeks, I’ve carried this lens around New York at night to see if it could replace my primes. In short: it really simplified my shooting. No more second-guessing focal lengths or switching lenses mid-scene.
I found myself gravitating toward the tighter end of the zoom, which matches the primes I use most. I was initially concerned about whether f/1.8 would be fast enough compared to my f/1.4 and f/1.2 primes. For about 98% of scenes, f/1.8 was plenty. In the rare cases I wanted more speed, I just bumped ISO, and with modern sensors plus Lightroom’s denoise tools, the results were totally usable.
Autofocus was quick and reliable, sharpness was excellent (as expected from Sigma’s Art line), and overall the lens felt clean and dependable.
Most importantly, this lens made me feel more present in the moment. Instead of overthinking gear choices, I just zoomed in or out and kept shooting.
Can It Replace My Primes?
Can the Sigma 17-40 f1.8 ART replace my prime lenses?
So, does it fully replace my prime kit? Honestly—not completely.
I still prefer the faster apertures (f/1.4 and f/1.2) in some cases.
The lens tops out at 40mm, so it can’t cover the tighter looks I get from my 56mm.
That said, the 17-40mm covers so much ground that I felt completely comfortable heading out with just this lens. If I had to choose, I’d probably pair it with the 56mm prime and call it a day. That combo would cover both focal length flexibility and low-light needs.
Would I Buy It?
I haven’t purchased it yet, but I do plan to add it to my kit. Once budget allows, I’ll likely make this my main carry for night photography. It really solves the analysis paralysis issue and lets me focus more on shooting.
Final Thoughts
The Sigma 17-40mm f/1.8 is an impressive lens, especially for Fuji X-Mount shooters who love working in low light. It doesn’t entirely replace primes, but it comes close—and in practice, it may simplify your shooting process in a way that primes can’t.
If you’re struggling with analysis paralysis or just want a versatile night photography lens, this one is definitely worth considering.
To watch a video version of this blog, visit this link to my YouTube here.
Help support my work by exploring my products below!
